Standard vs RAW Account (Which One Is Better?)
Standard and Raw accounts are the same market - only the pricing model changes. A Standard account hides the fee inside a wider spread. A Raw account shows a tighter spread and charges a separate commission. What’s “cheaper” depends on your trading style and how often you trade.
Risk warning: This content is for educational purposes only and not financial advice. Forex trading involves risk, and you can lose money.
Standard vs Raw: what actually changes
- Standard: spread-only pricing (broker markup is inside the spread).
- Raw: tight spreads + a separate commission per trade.
- Same chart, different bill: your fills and execution still matter (spreads can widen, slippage can happen).
All-in cost (the only comparison that matters)
- Standard all-in: average spread (that’s basically it).
- Raw all-in: average spread + commission.
- Simple rule: if the Raw spread is smaller by more than the commission “equivalent”, Raw is cheaper.
If you want to go deeper on fees: commission explained and fixed vs variable spreads.
When a Standard account is usually the better pick
- You trade less often: swing trades, occasional setups, longer holds.
- You want simplicity: one visible cost (spread) instead of spread + commission math.
- You trade small sizes: commission can feel “heavier” psychologically on tiny positions.
- You’re still learning execution: focusing on clean rules matters more than squeezing 0.2 pips.
When a Raw account is usually the better pick
- You trade frequently: scalping or many intraday entries/exits.
- You care about tight spreads: especially around liquid sessions where raw spreads stay low.
- You use precise entries: tighter spreads can help on breakouts, stop entries, and quick management.
- You’re comparing brokers properly: average spreads + commission + execution quality.
Common traps (why “Raw” is not automatically cheaper)
- Commission is per trade: more trades = more commission. Great if spreads are truly tight, bad if you overtrade.
- Spreads still widen: news, rollover and thin liquidity can blow out raw spreads too.
- Execution can dominate costs: slippage/requotes can cost more than the spread difference.
- Some “Raw” accounts aren’t truly raw: always verify the full pricing + execution model.
Useful deep dives: execution, slippage, and why spreads widen.
Quick checklist before you choose
- Average spread (not minimum): check typical spreads during the hours you trade.
- Commission details: per side or round-turn, and per lot size.
- Execution notes: do you see slippage, rejections, or “weird” spread spikes?
- Your style: scalper/intraday vs swing → pick the model that fits the frequency.
- Other costs: swap if you hold overnight → swap & rollover.
Simple beginner conclusion
- New traders: Standard is often fine while you build consistency.
- Active traders: Raw can be cheaper if the spreads are genuinely tight and execution is clean.
- Always compare all-in: spread + commission + execution.
